Pros & Cons: Flipping Compared to BRRRR

Here’s a detailed breakdown of the pros and cons of flipping a property versus using the BRRRR (Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat) strategy, considering critical factors such as time, financial risks, leverage, contractors, permits, holding costs, and more.

1. Time Commitment

Flipping

Pros:
- Faster Exit: A flip project typically lasts 4-12 months, depending on scope and market conditions. Once the property is sold, you can move on to the next project.
- Immediate Profit: You receive a lump-sum payout quickly upon sale.
Cons:
- Intense Short-Term Pressure: The entire process—finding a deal, rehabbing, managing contractors, marketing, and selling—requires significant time and effort in a short span.
- Market Risk: Timing the market poorly could reduce your profits. Delays extend holding costs and erode returns.

BRRRR

Pros:
- Long-Term Investment: BRRRR is a more gradual approach, as you hold the property long-term. The time pressure to refinance and rent is less intense than a flip.
- Cash Flow Over Time: Once rented, the property generates ongoing passive income.
Cons:
- Extended Time for Returns: Significant cash returns may take years to accumulate compared to the lump sum from a flip.
- Ongoing Time Commitment: Managing tenants and property maintenance requires continuous attention, especially if you self-manage.

2. Financial Risks

Flipping

Pros:
- High Profit Potential: If done correctly, flips can yield substantial returns (e.g., 10-30% ROI) in a short period.
Cons:
- High Financial Risk: Market fluctuations, underestimating rehab costs, or overestimating the ARV (After Repair Value) can result in losses.
- No Cash Flow: Until the property sells, you’re not generating income, only incurring expenses.
- All Capital at Stake: A failed flip means you lose all or most of your investment.

BRRRR

Pros:
- Diversified Returns: Even if the ARV is lower than expected, you can still generate rental income to cover costs.
- Long-Term Wealth Building: Holding the asset increases equity over time as rents appreciate and loans are paid down.
Cons:
- High Initial Investment: A poorly executed refinance may leave more capital tied up, reducing your ROI.
- Vacancy Risk: If tenants cannot be secured quickly, the property becomes a financial burden.

3. Debt Leverage

Flipping

Pros:
- Short-Term Use of Leverage: Loans (hard money, private lenders) are typically short-term, meaning less time paying interest.
Cons:
- Higher Borrowing Costs: Hard money loans or bridge loans carry high interest rates (10-15%+) and origination fees.
- Debt Must Be Repaid Quickly: If the property doesn’t sell on time, you may struggle to repay the loan or face foreclosure.

BRRRR

Pros:
- Long-Term Financing: You can secure low-interest, long-term loans (conventional or DSCR loans) after refinancing.
- Ongoing Leverage: By pulling cash out during the refinance phase, you can recycle funds to acquire additional properties.
Cons:
- Refinance Uncertainty: The loan terms depend on appraised value and rental income. A low appraisal can hinder your ability to recoup cash.
- Longer Exposure to Debt: Long-term mortgages mean you’re tied to debt for years.

4. Handling Contractors

Flipping

Pros:
- One-and-Done: The relationship with contractors ends once the project is complete.
Cons:
- Cost Overruns and Delays: Mismanagement or unreliable contractors can destroy profitability.
- Tighter Timelines: Flips are time-sensitive, so delays are more financially damaging.

BRRRR

Pros:
- More Flexibility: Since there’s no urgency to sell immediately, you can manage rehab in stages if needed.
Cons:
- Ongoing Contractor Relationships: If rehabbing multiple BRRRR projects, you’ll need to maintain longer-term relationships.

5. Managing Permits

Flipping

Cons:
- Speed vs. Permits: Flipping often involves significant structural or cosmetic work requiring permits. Delays caused by permit approval can significantly impact timelines and profits.

BRRRR

Pros:
- Fewer Permit Concerns: BRRRR strategies often focus on functional rehabs rather than high-end finishes, which might require fewer permits.

6. Holding Costs

Flipping

Cons:
- Short-Term Holding Costs: Mortgage interest, utilities, taxes, and insurance must be covered until the sale, eating into profits if the project drags on.

BRRRR

Pros:
- Stabilized Costs: Once the property is rented, the tenant effectively pays for holding costs.
Cons:
- Vacancy Risks: If you cannot place a tenant immediately, you’ll still face holding costs.

7. Finding Buyers vs. Finding Tenants

Flipping

Cons:
- Reliance on Market Demand: Selling requires finding a buyer willing to pay the ARV. A slow market can force price reductions.
- More Marketing Effort: You must stage and market the property to attract buyers quickly.

BRRRR

Pros:
- Steady Rental Demand: In most markets, demand for affordable rentals is strong, especially for well-maintained properties.
Cons:
- Tenant Placement Challenges: Finding quality tenants can take time and effort, especially if rents are above market rates.

8. Long-Term vs. Short-Term Rewards

Flipping

Pros:
- Lump-Sum Profit: Offers quick capital that can be reinvested into other deals or used for personal expenses.
Cons:
- No Long-Term Benefits: You forego potential appreciation, tax advantages, and passive income.

BRRRR

Pros:
- Wealth Accumulation: Allows you to build long-term wealth through appreciation, rental income, and equity.
- Tax Benefits: Rental properties offer tax deductions (depreciation, mortgage interest, repairs, etc.).
Cons:
- Lower Immediate Returns: The cash-out refinance might not cover all invested capital, and rental income builds slowly.

9. Taxes: Capital Gains and Borrowing Money

Flipping

Pros:

Deductible Expenses: Costs related to the flip, including repairs, interest on loans, and holding costs (e.g., property taxes, insurance), can be deducted as business expenses, reducing taxable income.
Short-Term Tax Flexibility: If flips are part of an active business, you can deduct losses against other income in the same tax year.

Cons:

High Tax Burden:
- Short-Term Capital Gains: Profits from flips held for less than one year are taxed as ordinary income (up to 37%, depending on your tax bracket). This can significantly reduce net profits.
- Flipping is considered an active business activity, so self-employment taxes (an additional 15.3%) may apply.
No Long-Term Tax Benefits: Since you’re selling quickly, you miss out on long-term capital gains rates (which are lower).

Example:

If you make a $50,000 profit on a flip and are in the 24% tax bracket, you would owe:

Federal Income Tax: 24% of $50,000 = $12,000
Self-Employment Tax: 15.3% of $50,000 = $7,650
Total Tax: $19,650, leaving you with $30,350 net profit.

BRRRR

Pros:

Tax-Advantaged Growth:
- No Immediate Tax on Cash-Out Refinancing: Borrowed money from refinancing is not taxable, as it’s considered a loan, not income. This allows you to access funds tax-free to invest in additional properties.
- Long-Term Capital Gains Rates: If you sell the property after holding it for more than one year, profits are taxed at the lower long-term capital gains rate (0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on income).
Depreciation Deduction: Rental properties allow you to deduct depreciation (a portion of the property’s value) each year, reducing taxable rental income.
Other Write-Offs: Mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, and maintenance costs are deductible against rental income.

Cons:

Depreciation Recapture: If you sell the property, the IRS requires you to recapture depreciation deductions at a rate of 25%, which adds to your tax burden.
Ongoing Tax on Rental Income: Net rental income is taxed as ordinary income annually, though deductions help offset this.

Example:

If you own a BRRRR property:

Rental Income: $12,000 annually
Expenses (interest, taxes, repairs): $7,000
Depreciation Deduction: $3,636 (on a $100,000 property over 27.5 years)
Taxable Income: $12,000 – $7,000 – $3,636 = $1,364
If you’re in the 24% tax bracket, you’d owe only $327 in taxes on rental income.

If you refinance and pull out $40,000, you pay no taxes on that money because it’s a loan.

Summary Table: Taxes on Flip vs. BRRRR

Tax Consideration	Flipping	BRRRR
Capital Gains	Short-term gains taxed as ordinary income.	Long-term gains taxed at lower rates.
Self-Employment Taxes	Additional 15.3% tax for active income.	Not applicable to rental income.
Tax on Borrowed Money	N/A – no loans upon sale.	Refinanced cash-out is not taxable.
Deductions	Repairs, holding costs, loan interest.	Depreciation, mortgage interest, taxes, etc.
Depreciation Recapture	N/A (no long-term hold).	25% recapture when sold.
Annual Rental Income Tax	N/A (no rental income).	Taxed as ordinary income but offset by deductions.

Key Takeaways:

Flipping is tax-heavy, especially with short-term capital gains and self-employment taxes. To optimize taxes, you need to flip quickly and manage write-offs effectively.
BRRRR is tax-efficient due to depreciation, write-offs, and the ability to borrow tax-free through refinancing. Long-term capital gains rates further improve the tax outlook when selling.

For investors focused on tax efficiency and leveraging funds, BRRRR has a clear edge.

–

As a disclaimer, I’m not a licensed attorney or tax professional so please do your own research and know that every investment includes financial risks. These are merely my opinions and observations.

Need Expert Advice?

For personalized guidance on choosing the right strategy and maximizing your real estate investments, contact Cody McDonald, a trusted expert in real estate investing. Cody can help you analyze opportunities, navigate risks, and create a plan tailored to your goals.

Get in touch with Cody McDonald today to take your investing strategy to the next level! Subscribe now and check out macdoesrei.com!

REI Education